It's tempting to think you can just compare unit prices. You see a quote for a Metso HP200 bowl liner at $X, and an aftermarket option at 60% of that. Simple math, right? I've made that mistake. In Q2 2024, I compared costs across 4 vendors for a quarterly order of wear parts for our HP200 cone crushers. Vendor A (OEM) quoted $48,000. Vendor B (reputable aftermarket) quoted $34,000. I almost went with B until I calculated the TCO over 6 months.
The aftermarket liners wore out in 5 weeks. The Metso OEM set lasted 9 weeks. When you factor in the cost of a liner changeout—$2,800 in crane time, labor for 4 guys, and 12 hours of lost production at $15,000/hour—the OEM cost per operating hour was actually lower. It's not just about the part price.
According to Metso's publicly available brochures (2024), their wear parts are engineered with specific metallurgy and heat treatment for the machine. That often translates to extended life in specific crushing conditions. But is it always worth it? Nope. I recommend Metso OEM for critical, high-wear items on your primary crusher. But if you're dealing with a secondary or tertiary cone where downtime isn't as painful, a certified aftermarket supplier can be a solid cost-saving option. That's a nuance the 'always buy OEM' crowd ignores.
This is the million-dollar question, and the answer changes depending on your setup and risk tolerance. Over the past 7 years of tracking every invoice in our procurement system, I've developed a hard rule for what we never buy aftermarket.
1. The Hydraulic System Components (For Cone Crushers Like HP200)
We didn't have a formal verification process for hydraulic cylinder seals once. Cost us when a non-OEM seal failed, causing a contamination event that led to a $22,000 repair bill on a main shaft assembly. The 'cheap' option resulted in a $1,200 redo when quality failed.
2. Fine Adjustment Rings and Locking Collars
The thread tolerances from aftermarket suppliers can be inconsistent. In 2023, we had a locking collar seize on an HP300 because the threads weren't cut to the exact METSO specification. That 3-day downtime cost us more than the price of 10 OEM collars combined.
3. Eccentric Assemblies and Main Shafts
The 'average quality' advice ignores the fact that these parts handle extreme fatigue stress. We sourced a main shaft from an alternative manufacturer once. It lasted 7 months. The Metso OEM shaft we replaced it with is still going strong after 18 months. I still kick myself for that decision. If I'd spent the extra $1,400 upfront, I'd have saved $3,000 in changeout costs.
For anything that can cause a catastrophic failure or requires precision machining (like the hydraulic system), stick with OEM. For wear liners, it's a case-by-case decision based on your feed material and product requirements.
Not directly, no. Metso equipment is designed with a specific geometry that doesn't match up with a Sandvik or a Terex machine. I've heard operators ask this thinking they can find a universal part. The mounting points, the drive configuration, the chamber shape—they're proprietary. Trying to retrofit a Metso HP200 component onto another brand is a recipe for machine damage and safety issues.
That said, if you're a straight truck customer looking at mining equipment, you might be dealing with a mixed fleet. Our operation runs both Sandvik and Metso equipment. We keep separate inventory for each. The only cross-brand part we've found that works reliably is generic hydraulic hoses and standard filters. For anything specific to the crusher—no, don't try it. Trust me on this one.
Fake parts are a real problem in the mining industry. We've seen parts that look identical—the packaging, the logo, the paint color—but are made of inferior materials. I once audited a shipment of HP200 mantle liners that looked perfect. But the hardness check showed they were way too soft. They would have failed in a week.
Here's my 3-step verification process:
1. Check the Supplier Against the Metso Dealer Locator
Use the official Metso website to find authorized dealers. If the supplier isn't listed, ask for proof of their distribution agreement. "We buy from an authorized source" isn't enough. Get the source name.
2. Look for the Metso Part Number and QR Code
Genuine parts have a specific format for their part numbers and serial numbers. Metso has started using QR codes on many wear parts that link to their authentication system. If a part has a generic label, it's a red flag.
3. The Price Test
If a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is. We almost got burned on a $6,000 order for "surplus" spare parts. The price was 40% below any other quote. We did a background check on the supplier. Turns out they had a history of selling counterfeit parts. We dodged a $20,000 repair bill.
This is a great area to save money if you know what you're looking at. We've had excellent success with rebuilt hydraulic power units and some gear drives from a third-party rebuild shop that specializes in mining equipment. But it's not a blanket recommendation.
When we buy rebuilt:
When we stay away:
I recommend this for non-critical components because the cost savings can be 30-50% over OEM. But if you're dealing with a part that your operations manager says "we can't have this fail," just buy OEM new.
In 2022, we bought a rebuilt Metso HP200 hydraulic power unit for $8,200. OEM new was $15,500. It's been running for 3 years without any issues. But I wouldn't buy a rebuilt main shaft. The risk vs. reward isn't there. This is about knowing your machine and your risk profile. This solution works for 80% of our cases. Here's how to know if you're in the other 20%: if a failure means your entire plant stops for more than a day, go OEM new.
Our application engineers answer crusher and screen selection questions at no charge.
Ask an Expert